Death doesn’t arrive politely. It interrupts. It is unsettling. And in its aftermath, we’re left not only with grief, but with decisions. One of the most personal of these is how we say goodbye. Do we follow tradition? Or do we reimagine the moment? In recent years, more families have found themselves standing at a quiet crossroads—between a traditional funeral and a celebration of life. This isn't just about logistics. It's about meaning, emotion, and legacy. And it's worth thinking about—gently, but honestly.
Via Unsplash
The Traditional Funeral: Ritual, Reverence, and Routine
Traditional funerals are anchored in centuries of ritual. They tend to follow a predictable structure: a visitation, a formal service, and often a burial. There’s comfort in this formality. The cadence of hymns, the eulogy, the closed or open casket—they give mourners a framework when everything else feels unsteady.
Religion often plays a central role here. Prayers, scripture readings, and clerical officiants help frame the loss through a spiritual lens. Even when not overtly religious, the tone is typically solemn. Grief is present and visible. For many, this structure is grounding. But for others, it may feel too heavy, or disconnected from the life their loved one actually lived.
Celebrations of Life: Personal, Playful, Profound
Enter the celebration of life—a less formal, often more uplifting alternative. There may be no casket. No suits. No hymns or pews. Instead, there might be laughter, photo collages, favourite songs, and storytelling that reflects the person in vivid colour rather than sombre black and white.
Imagine a gathering at a beach, or a potluck in a sun-drenched garden. Maybe there’s a playlist of old rock classics, or a table filled with things your loved one adored—crumpled paperback novels, gardening gloves, jazz records, dog treats.
Celebrations of life don’t deny grief. They just give it a different shape. They allow people to honour a memory without being bound by rules that might not fit.
So… Which Is Right?
There’s no universal answer—only what feels right for your family, your beliefs, and the life you're remembering. Sometimes, a hybrid approach makes the most sense. A short formal service, followed by a laid-back gathering. Or a traditional funeral first, then a casual celebration a few weeks later when emotions have settled.
When beginning your funeral planning, consider the tone you want to strike. What would comfort those left behind? What would make your loved one smile if they could peek in? It's okay to break from tradition if that tradition doesn’t serve you. And it's also okay to embrace it fully, if that’s where your heart leans.
A Quiet Word on Permission
One of the most profound things anyone ever said about grief is this: You’re allowed to do it your way. That includes the goodbye.
There’s no “right” level of formality, no checklist you must follow. Whether you sit in silence or tell stories over barbecue ribs, whether you wear black or burnt orange, whether you light candles or laughter—what matters is the intention. The love. The remembering. And maybe, just maybe, the understanding that this choice is not about death. It’s about the life that came before it.